The Multiverse continues to evolve and with the introduction of Green Lantern, The Flash, and Hawkgirl, it’s time for The Atom to make his appearance. Matthew and Stephen dive into the issues in this week’s Major Spoilers Dueling Review.

EARTH 2 #4
Writer: James Robinson
Artists: Nicola Scott and Eduardo Pansica
Inkers: Revor Scott and Sean Parsons
Colorists: Alex Sinclair and Tony Avina
Letterer: Travis Lanham
Publisher: DC Comics
Cover Price: $2.99

Previously in Earth 2: Having lost the love of his life in a tragic train crash, Alan Scott became Earth 2’s Green Lantern. Meanwhile, Hawkgirl and The Flash test each other’s powers as The Rot takes hold in Washington D.C.

MATTHEW: This issue opens with another quick origin recap, this one of “Captain Pratt,” who for the benefit of those in the cheap seats, is almost certainly The Atom, Al Pratt. The Flash and Hawkgirl are all drawn to the center of the Rot incursion, finding an angry gray monster (Solomon Grundy) who continues to cry out for the Green Knight. Cue Alan Scott, in a very New 52 Superman-inspired armor to pit the green against the gray (just like in the Civil War, assuming one is color-blind.)

STEPHEN: We’ve seen the gods get involved in giving The Flash his powers, it looks like the hand of something big was involved in The Atom’s creation. Too bad we don’t learn more about that here.

MATTHEW: That’s the problem with a large cast, especially one that is getting multiple origins. We barely know anything about Hawkgirl, and Flash and Green Lantern’s origins are a bit hazy in the middle, as well…

STEPHEN: Also, is it just me, or are there a number of grammatical and spelling errors in the issue that should have been caught before the book made it to the printer?

MATTHEW: There are certainly grammar issues, and Rodrigo’s proverbial “Wall O’ Text” is in full effect in these pages.

STEPHEN: My biggest complaint with this issue is the same problem I had with the last, James Robinson’s dialogue feels so…broken. Like — wait. That’s kind of hard… to follow… ya get — where I’m… coming from? It flows better when read out loud, but I don’t know too many people who read their comics that way, save those those whose lips move when they read; those people creep me out.

MATTHEW: Being someone who hears the voices of the characters in his head as he read, I wasn’t as bothered by it, but Robinson does engage in some quasi-Hemingway sentence fragments, and a number of lines only make sense if you do read it aloud. And you’re only creeped out because you think they’re talking about you. It’s the same reason you dislike groups of people speaking other languages while you’re around.

STEPHEN: Overall I’m not totally disappointed with the story, but it feels very much like the first six or so issues of the Justice League series. At this point, unless something spectacular happens, I’m in for two more issue, and then this will be a digital edition, only when I feel like purchasing it book.

MATTHEW: I’m not disappointed with what story we’re given here, but there’s an issue with portion size. We don’t know what, precisely, is the Atom’s deal, other than it entwines with Hawkgirl’s likewise unexplained backstory, and as charming as The Flash and Green Lantern are in certain sequences (there’s a clear effort to establish Alan as this world’s greatest archetypical hero), I just don’t feel like I know enough about the characters (save for the 80 years of now-moot stories I’ve already read.) Both of their powers are magical in nature, and give them immediate motivations, apparently, but the plot seems to be a shark, moving forward lest it die.

STEPHEN: I mentioned this about another DC title I reviewed recently – why are there so many artists on a single book? Has the monthly release deadline hit the creators so hard that they have to bring in others to help finish the issue in time?

MATTHEW: The New 52 made a guarantee that the books would be on-time. If you make a rule that must not be broken, you better be ready to bend over backwards and not break the thing.

STEPHEN: Do the multiple artists work in this issue?

MATTHEW: Honestly, until you mentioned it, I hadn’t realized that there WERE multiple artists involved, so make of that what you will.


STEPHEN: Though I get where Mr. Robinson is coming from, and the art is well done, overall, I’m rather bored with this story. It doesn’t have the gee-wiz factor that the emergence of heroes in a world that needs heroes should have. Best I can do is give this issue 2.5 out of 5 Stars.

Rating: ★★½☆☆

MATTHEW: The Flash follows a trail of Rot this issue, while Green Lantern’s magic draws him right to where he’s supposed to be. Those plot devices were a bit obvious, and I’m still kind of in the dark about lots of things here, probably by design. While I enjoyed the issue more than, say, The Ravagers, I can’t necessarily sell this as a great title yet. The pieces seem to be all there, but I’m still on the fence, and can’t give Earth 2 #4 more than 3 out of 5 Stars overall. The JSA lover in me wants to embrace this book fully, but I’m finding a little bit of ‘Cry For Justice’ syndrome in these pages, and don’t want to get burned that bad again.

Rating: ★★★☆☆

ROBOT OVERLORD: Two similar opinions from two nearly indistinguishable meatbags. It’s no wonder that they’re so easily hypnotized with cartoons and fermented hops.

Overall Rating: ★★★☆☆

About Author

Stephen Schleicher began his career writing for the Digital Media Online community of sites, including Digital Producer and Creative Mac covering all aspects of the digital content creation industry. He then moved on to consumer technology, and began the Coolness Roundup podcast. A writing fool, Stephen has freelanced for Sci-Fi Channel's Technology Blog, and Gizmodo. Still longing for the good ol' days, Stephen launched Major Spoilers in July 2006, because he is a glutton for punishment. You can follow him on Twitter @MajorSpoilers and tell him your darkest secrets...


  1. This may just be me. But I think the wall of text kind of adds to the comic. It pulls up the feeling of a much older comic. The, stilted I guess is the best word, stilted speaking style feels the same way too.
    One thing though that feels very modern is the pacing. We are very obviously in a six issue arc. (Well, I’m assuming the 6 issue part, but in an arc). The issue stands less well on its own because it’s part of the over all arc introducing the Justice Society, (or at least the super-types on Earth-2).

  2. Honestly I’ve enjoyed this book a lot, and I think that’s largely because the fact of not knowing is being addressed. When I look at this vs Justice League, in JL #1-6 we got a team that was newly forged in the heat of battle, and as a results didn’t work as a unit. But in #7 we immediately see a team that works like a well oiled machine, with LOADS of story that we clearly missed. (Example discussion of the Boom Tubes failiing and sending them to Apokolips, I wanted to read that story!). Here at least we see a group of people, all familiar with the idea of superheroes, but no one with any experience, being pulled together and made into a team, and too me, Robinson isn’t just going to jump ahead, we are seeing a team not only form, but be forged into the force that is the Justice Society. I think the book could benefit from some more time to expand on topics and story points, but I definitely thinking that given the time Robinson will. This is probably one of those books that will read better in trade for many.

  3. I like the story so far. They’ve managed with a few updates and changes (Scott’s sexual orientation, Al Pratt having the combined powers of his pre-52 sons, Damage and Atom Smasher, Flash being the youngest of the group rather than the oldest, Mr. Terrific’s a villian…) to make this a different story but with a good tip of the hat to the “Golden Age” to make old fans like me stay interested. It’s really scary that the one DC character that I always related to (the Original Atom, Al Pratt) is now being portrayed as even MORE like a certain old commentator was in his younger days. I have to admit a bit of glee at seeing him basically stomp Grundy into the ground and make his appearance as a guy with a major power set. YES!

  4. I have no real problem with the dialog (could be because i do not speak english as a native language).
    The conversation with the green flame was awkward but i feel it would be in any way it would happen. It’s a talking green flame you guys!

    On the other hand, this is not Earth. People talk differently but maybe they do because it’s a different world with different (language) rules. That explanation is cheap but it works for me…

  5. ~wyntermute~ on

    Hawkgirl looks kinda like “New52 Dovegirl With Guns”? I like blue/white as a color-scheme, but it’s not exactly what one is used to seeing “Hawkgirl” wearing…

  6. Allen Scott’s origins seem straightforward enough… He was chosen by the Green. To fight against the Rot. He’s meant to protect using its own Green energy… he’s Swamp Thing!

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.