Major Spoilers
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Twitch Discord RSS
    Major Spoilers
    • Home
    • Reviews
      • Random Access Memory
      • Retro Review
      • So You Want to Read Comics
    • Podcasts
      • Critical Hit
        • Critical Hit House Rules
        • Critical Hit World Building
      • Dueling Review
      • Finally Friday
      • Geek History Lesson
      • The Legion Clubhouse
      • Major Spoilers Podcast
        • MSP TPB for 2019
        • On the Next Major Spoilers Podcast – 2013
        • On the Next Major Spoilers Podcast – 2012
        • On the Next Major Spoilers Podcast – 2011
      • Munchkin Land
      • Top Five
      • Wayne’s Comics
      • Zach on Film
    • Features
      • Casual 60
      • Comic Casting Couch
      • Comics Portal
      • Did You Hear?
      • Editorials
      • Features
      • Gamer’s Corner
      • Hero Histories
      • Let’s Get Nerdy
      • Major Spoilers Adventures
      • Random Access Memory
      • So You Want to Read Comics
    • Movies
      • Did You Hear
      • Movies
      • Television
    • Comic Previews
    • Patreon
      • Patreon
      • Store
    Major Spoilers
    DC

    REVIEW: Batgirl #2

    Matthew PetersonBy Matthew PetersonOctober 13, 2011Updated:October 13, 201110 Comments5 Mins Read

    Or – “Batwoman Stole Most Of Her Old Look Anyway…”

    I think that the cover of issue #2 has hit on what has been bothering me about this relaunched character:  Barbara Gordon, while essentially the same, has been considerably de-aged conceptually.  It’s nearly impossible to imagine the mid-30ish Oracle, a former Congresswoman and a match for Bruce Wayne himself in the shoes that the first issue put her.  This cover shows a young woman of maybe 25 years of age, and with that realization, something clicked in my head, putting issue #1 in a whole new light.  Will #2 give me more food for thought?

    BATGIRL #2
    Writer: Gail Simone
    Penciller: Ardian Syaf
    Inker: Vicente Cifuentes
    Colorist: Ulises Arreola
    Letterer: Dave Sharpe
    Editor: Bobbie Chase
    Publisher: DC Comics
    Cover Price $2.99

    Previously, in Batgirl:  Barbara Gordon’s career as Batgirl was interrupted by a bullet from the Joker which left her paralyzed and in a wheelchair for several years.  Now, she’s back in action, and has found a new home, a new lease on life, and even a new boyfriend candidate.  Unfortunately for Batgirl, she’s also found a new villain who fits in perfectly with the rest of the Gotham City lunatic fringe, and he’s targeting her specifically (in both her Batgirl AND Barbara identities.)  Will The Mirror put Batgirl back on the shelf?

    FIRST, WE GET SOME OF THE BAT…

    This issue picks up literally seconds after last issue and the confrontation during which Batgirl froze at the sight of the Mirror’s gun.  Her hesitation led to an innocent man taking a bullet, and as we open, The Mirror makes his escape.  Having read all of the relaunched Bat-titles, I find it interesting that this book and Batwoman are the most accessible for me, and as Batgirl leaps into action, I remember why.  The Mirror is more than a match for her physically, and out-thinks her high above the city, causing her to take a damn near fatal spill.  I can’t imagine Bruce Wayne (or even Dick Grayson) being put in the same situation and having it work.  On the down side, I can’t imagine the writers ever putting Bruce Wayne in that situation, but Gail Simone’s writing makes the sequence work, as Barbara tries to shake off the rust from three years off the streets, and has to remember what it is that she’s best at.  There’s also some strong character work with Detective McKenna, the partner of the Gotham City cop that the Mirror killed last ish, as she shows herself to be strong and driven in kind of a Renee Montoya vein, and I’m quite certain that we’ll be seeing more of her in the future.

    …THEN, WE GET SOME OF THE GIRL.

    Batgirl trails the Mirror to the last cemetery within the city limits of Gotham, and Barbara muses about WHY it is still where it is (rich folks have pull.)  For some heroes, this information would have seemed out-of-place, or overly expository, but for Batgirl it helps to put across the fact that she’s always thinking, always processing, and that she remembers everything she’s ever read.  (At least, pre-Crisis, she did.  I don’t know if Barbara’s photographic memory even made it past the ’86 CoIE, much less this latest revamp.)  Batgirl makes mistakes in this issue, but regains her stride when she starts connecting the dots, honoring her intel-gathering roots as Oracle, and I really fell in love with her new roomie during their interactions.  (Short form:  New roomie believed that the obviously injured Barbara had been beaten up by a boyfriend rather than a crazed super-villain, and was ready to call the cops on him, a very effective scene.)  Things end with another big cliffhanger, as Batgirl discovers that Mirror’s true identity, but finds that he is a step or two ahead of her.

    THE VERDICT: MANY THINGS BROUGHT TO LIGHT…

    Last issue, like many of the DC New 52 #1’s, hit the ground running and gave it’s all to set a dynamic tone.  This issue slows down a bit, building some relationships with Daddy Gordon, with the roommate, with the new boyfriend, and gives The Mirror not only a tragic origin, but a wild-eyed demeanor that makes him unnerving as all hell.  The fact that Batgirl is physically overpowered by the villain and has to reconfigure her battle plan comes across very well, and the art throughout the issue is moody and interesting without falling into the trap of being dark and muddy.  Ardian Syaf delivers a younger Batgirl, and makes her completely believable as a young woman and as a superhero, which is a tough proposition, and his mirror effects are pretty cool throughout the issue.  Overall, Batgirl #2 is an improvement on #1 (which, since I didn’t review it, I should clarify was about a 3 star book for me) and makes me less worried about the larger character arc for Barbara Gordon, earning 4 out of 5 stars overall.

    [rating: 4/5]

    Faithful Spoilerite Question Of The Day:  Is there really anything wrong with a grown woman deciding (in-universe, mind you) to self-identify as a BatGIRL?

    Batgirl DC Gail Simone New 52 Review
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleNEW 52 REVIEW: Huntress #1
    Next Article NYCC’11: Vincente Alcazar introduces new series at comc con
    Matthew Peterson
    • Website
    • Twitter

    Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture! And a nice red uniform.

    Related Posts

    Top Five Movies 2005-2010 Edition

    Read More

    Fantastic Four #1 Review

    Read More

    Major Spoilers Podcast #1133: The Fight of the Century

    Read More

    10 Comments

    1. TaZ on October 14, 2011 12:01 am

      Any thoughts on the “Professor Stein is Alive” graffiti on the back of the elevated train?

      • Stephen Schleicher on October 14, 2011 12:04 am

        Sure… I hear it is one of the reasons Gail Simone is leaving the Firestorm title.

        • J Michael T on October 14, 2011 12:21 am

          Whu-? What?!? Oh my. Clevinger to the rescue?

          • J Michael T on October 14, 2011 11:52 am

            If you are asking me, I meant it in a good way but not saying her work on the title was bad. Firestorm was one of my favorite relaunches, but I saw the ideas Clevinger submitted for the character and they sounded awesome. Simone is still one of my favorite writers but hers was a somewhat controversial choice for the title at the time.

        • websnap on October 14, 2011 11:46 am

          how do you mean? In a positive way or negative way?

      • Matthew Peterson on October 14, 2011 11:24 am

        Any thoughts on the “Professor Stein is Alive” graffiti on the back of the elevated train?

        CORPORATE! SYNERGYYYYY!

        I think it’s a cool nod that the writer put in before she left the Firestorm book, but I don’t have Stephen’s connections…

    2. Ced on October 14, 2011 8:50 am

      Yes, I think that with her age and experience, Barbara Gordon should have a more mature bat-identity. It would be interesting if after retaking her bat girl identity, Barbara realize she have grown up over the girl character. But I guess it can’t happen due to the title branding of the book.

    3. Chris B on October 15, 2011 9:14 am

      I like the writing and characterization. I do.

      But I haven’t yet gotten an idea of what makes her particularly special. I mean, so far we’ve only seen her fight some random yahoos (constantly expressing how frightened she was the whole time), and a guy who beat the heck out of her. That same guy then ruined her one relatively impressive accomplishment by making it a trap.

      Most of the time, one of the many things we see in the first issue or two is to see what awesomeness makes this character “super.” It seems like every time Babs does something remotely impressive, there’s something to weigh it down in a way where it just doesn’t seem impressive any more.

      She’s very good at martial arts and acrobatics, but obsesses over whether she’s messing up. She’s fast on her feet, but freezes whenever she thinks she may be put back in a wheelchair. She’s a great researcher, but doesn’t think far enough ahead. I mean, I appreciate that Simone is giving us a fully fleshed out character instead of a super cardboard cut out, but that characterization is sort of sapping what makes her special.

      • Ced on October 15, 2011 9:42 am

        Good observation. I wonder if this could be linked to her “girl” status. Like you known, since she is “just a girl” she must be just at a sidekick level and can’t be too super on her own (like Batwoman for example).

        • Chris B on October 15, 2011 6:39 pm

          Don’t know. It does seem that Gail Simone is trying to show us someone who’s much greener than the pre-relaunch Babs, but I never got that she looked at Batgirl as a sidekick. In the past, she’s talked up the fact that she wasn’t a sidekick as one of the things that made her unique.

    AMAZON AFFILIATE

    Support this site by making a purchase through our Amazon affiliate links

    Reviews
    8.7
    July 11, 2025

    Fantastic Four #1 Review

    6.0
    July 8, 2025

    JSA #9 Review

    7.0
    July 7, 2025

    X-Men: Hellfire Vigil #1 Review

    5.7
    July 6, 2025

    Gehenna: Naked Aggression #1 Review

    7.0
    July 6, 2025

    Retro Review: Big Apple Comix (September 1975)

    Patreon Support
    Sponsor

    ComiXology Home Page

    Follow Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Twitch
    Major Spoilers Patreon
    • About
      • Major Spoilers Terms of Use
      • Major Spoilers Frequently Asked Questions
      • Major Spoilers Privacy Policy Statement
      • Major Spoilers Podcast Gear
    • Contact
    • Cookie Policy (EU)
    Major Spoilers is copyright 2006-2025 by Major Spoilers Entertainment, LLC

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
    Cookie settingsACCEPT
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    SAVE & ACCEPT