Or – “Is This The One Where They Find The Cap-Cave Under Stately Rogers Manor?”

With the parallels between Captain America and Batman these days, I keep expecting Jarvis to come out, sew up Steve’s wounds and make a few snarky comments.  Or perhaps the Red Skull will shoot American Dream in the spine, causing her to become the nerve center of Avengers operations as Delphi?  Oooh, wait, I got it!  Fred Barnes, the dead Bucky from the Fifties will come back and try to steal Bucky’s identity from him, all the while acting as a villain called the Star-Spangled Shawl!  This is comic book gold, friends, COMIC BOOK GOLD!

Steve Rogers, Super-Soldier #3

Previously, on Steve Rogers, Super-Soldier:  By my count, the origin of Captain America gets retold every five to ten years or so.  Each time, we are given new details (*coughretconscough*) of what really happened during the experiments of Project: Super-Soldier, now retconned to be the Weapon I project.  Oddly enough, this retelling has once again revealed heretofore untold nuggets of information about the origins of Captain America.  It seems that, unseen in any previous version, Steve Rogers fell in love with a mysterious woman during that time, and finds her near-double in a woman who is coincidentally married to the grandson of Professor Erskine (nee Reinstein), the developer of the Super-Soldier formula.  Erskine, Jr is assassinated, and a mysterious someone or someones has been revealed to be using the Super-Soldier formula to create his own musclebound goon squad, completely ignoring the psychotoic side-effects of the formula when used without the Vita-Ray treatment.  Tracking down the wife, Steve Rogers is shocked to discover that she’s not an undead Nazi spy at all, but a robot double, a pawn in a game engineered by one of his oldest and most dangerous foes.  Interested yet?  Read on!

Commander Rogers opens this issue with a reminiscence of his youth during  the Great Depression, as the other kids ganged up on him and beat him down whenever possible, just because he was skinny and sickly.  Flash-forward and we see why this thought has occurred to him, as Samuel Starr (aka the Machinesmith) has neutralized the Super-Soldier formula in his blood, reverting him to his original 90-pound-weakling state.  Machinesmith is, by Steve’s own description, a super-genius whose creations uploaded his brain into a robot form upon his death, leading to a mind that travels from machine to machine, “like the internet, only slightly more evil.”  Heh…   ‘Smith reveals that his plan all along was to use the deluded Erskine, Jr. to find the secret of why the formula has only ever worked on Rogers, which explains both how he knew about the pretty spy that Steve fell for and how he was able to create such an enticing trap.  Cap is knocked out by a burly SSF-enhanced thug and taken away, but there’s one thing that the Machinesmith didn’t count on, one thing that I’m sure will make every Captain America fan smile, and will support my theory that Batman and Captain America are actually the same guy:  He’s still dangerous, even if he’s just human. 

Okay, it’s actually a little more ingenious than that.  When Machinesmith’s thugs try to move him, the former Captain America uses his knowledge of martial arts and combat to defeat them using nothing more than his shirt and their own weapons.  “[All my] training didn’t simply VANISH, just because Machinesmith somehow turned off the Super-Solder formula in me.”  Commander Rogers dispatches them all in a (pretty impressive) show of combat training, a sequence that Dale Eaglesham renders just beautifully.  Steve makes his way back to the lab and engages the assistance of the Robot-Duplicate-Nazi-Spy-Love-Interest, who has just enough faux-humanity in her to want to help him.  With her help and a dose of Vita-Rays, Captain America is back to his normal Triple H proportions, and lays into another squad of goons.  There’s some nice character work here, as well, as Steve takes the time to deliver the beat-down to the thugs because he can’t abide a bully, and resents them using Erskine’s formula as a glorified steroid.  It’s nice work all around, as Steve and Robo-Girl hit the highway in pursuit of the Machinesmith, who plans to sell the Super-Soldier formula to the highest bidder.

This series got off to a pretty slow start for me, with yet another shoe-horned 1940’s love interest (although she may be the same Nazi girlfriend that appeared in the ‘Adventures of Captain America’ miniseries in the 90’s) and some blah-blah-blah about Professor Erskine’s son, who should rightly be much older by any count that I can come up with, but it recovers nicely here.  This particular issue gives us more than we usually get from Steve “Elder Statesman With The Pep Talks And The Glayvin” Rogers, showing us WHY he’s so indomitable, and giving us a first-person narrative that lets us in his head.  Ed Brubaker is good with this character, and as much as I mock the whole “We’re better because we’re more human!” school of super-heroic thought, it works when it’s not overworked.  (Batman, anyone?)  My main complaints are incidental (we’ve seen the whole scrawny Steve-thing before, we’ve seen Captain America without super-soldier formula before, and by the way, didn’t they remove it from his system back when Mark Gruenwald was writing the book?) to the fact that it’s a good story, drawn well, and makes me like a character whom I historically enjoy more as part of an ensemble cast.  Steve Rogers Super-Soldier #3 did something a lot of comics never do:  It pleasantly (albeit mildly) surprised me, and earns a very respectable 4 out of 5 stars overall.  (Given the nature of the character, maybe it should be 40 out of 50?)

Rating: ★★★★☆

Faithful Spoilerite Question Of The Day:  Has Nazi superspy Cynthia Glass ever appeared anywhere else before?


About Author

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture! And a nice red uniform.


  1. Ya know the parallels between Batman and Cap always make me think at the awesome JLA/Avengers crossover where it was shown that when come to fighting abilities and tactical skills they are pretty much on same level(with Bats getting a bonus for being a bit more stealthy)

  2. Rob (fka Smith) on

    I thought the scientist was supposed to be Erskine’s grandson. He had a different name prior to the change because he was the son of Erskine’s daughter, as such he had his father’s name.

    • I thought the scientist was supposed to be Erskine’s grandson. He had a different name prior to the change because he was the son of Erskine’s daughter, as such he had his father’s name.

      You are correct, sir… Good catch!

  3. This is a good example of a “Heroic Age” comic. These are the sort of stories I remember from my youth (was that also the 1940’s?).

    I’m glad to see an issue so reminiscent of that. There’s no better character to exemplify the Heroic Age than Steve Rogers.

    • I don’t really agree on that. Spiderman is a whinny guy named Peter Parker with a mask and superpowers who uses “Spiderman” to cover up the fact that, despite the powers, he’s still just the super-hero version of Eyore.

      There isn’t really a “Bruce Wayne”. Ever since he donned the costume and cowl, he’s “really” Batman and Bruce Wayne has been a false persona developed to protect The Bat.

      The similarities between Captain America and Batman are in their fighting skills and personalities. They are the least “powered” heroes of their respective groups but they are often seen as the true tactical leaders. When one can give an order and Thor, Hercules and The Hulk jump and the other has more influence than Superman, Wonder Woman or Martian Manhunter then that shows the similarities there. They are both natural tacticians and they can work as well alone as with a team. One may have been a 90 pound weakling patriot and the other a scared orphan boy but both are far beyond that now.

      Spiderman is still yet to grow a set.

      • There isn’t really a “Bruce Wayne”. Ever since he donned the costume and cowl, he’s “really” Batman and Bruce Wayne has been a false persona developed to protect The Bat.

        I have never liked that argument, simply because Batman is motivated by the murder of his innocent parents. Bruce Wayne is the key driving factor for Batman, and the points where the franchise has gone furthest off the rails is when the editorial staff clearly subscribes to the “There is no Bruce Wayne” theory.

  4. Cynthia Glass’ first appearance was in Adventures of Captain America Vol. 1 #1 from 1991 and she was in issues 2-4 as well, and then obviously more recently in this series. That’s it though from what I can tell.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.