Cobra as a peacekeeping force?  The Joe team disbanded?  Black is white, up is down and short is long, but what are the shattered remains of G.I. Joe gonna do about it?  Your Major Spoilers review of G.I. Joe #1 awaits!

GIJoe1CoverG.I. JOE #1
Writer: Karen Traviss
Penciler: Steve Kurth
Colorist: Kito Young
Letterer: Tom B. Long
Editor: John Barber
Publisher: IDW Publishing
Cover Price: $3.99

Previously in G.I. Joe:G.I. Joe is the code name of an elite special missions force whose mission is to defend the world from Cobra, a ruthless terrorist organization bent on ruling the world.”

But now, everything has changed.

PRETTY BLEAK STORY

There’s a lot of setup in this issue, with two parallel stories: Cobra, under the public leadership of Tomax (less his deceased twin brother Xamot) has become a peacekeeping force in troubled nations, while G.I. Joe (under the command of Scarlett, with assistance from Joe Colton, the original G.I. Joe) fights to keep her team funded in the new world order.  I’ve seen a lot of G.I. Joe stories, and the ones that I find the least compelling are the ones that deal with lots of realpolitik and funding issues and the like, and this issue is chockfull of such moments.  There are only five Joes in the book (possibly only five left): Roadblock, Mainframe, Scarlett, Flint and Agent Helix, and halfway through the issue they take their first mission as a fighting force.  Unfortunately for me, it’s a request to assassinate the leaders of the resistance in the same country where Cobra has stepped in as moderator.  This issue features a LOT of dialogue, and the only part of it that really pops for me is an exchange between Tomax and The Baroness (bless her leather-clad heart) wherein she calls him to task for the fact that Cobra isn’t DOING anything any more.  Tomax’s argument that they need to capture hearts and minds to defeat G.I. Joe is a strong one, and informs most of the new direction.

SOME COOL LINEWORK

Although I rather dislike this issue’s cover, I’m very happy with the interior work.  Steve Kurth’s artwork has a roughcut quality to it that fits the tone nicely, although the coloring is a bit bland during most of the issue.  There aren’t any battle sequences to speak of, so I can’t tell you for sure how I feel about his work in action, but the quiet moments have nice resonance to them, even as his facial expressions are a bit loose and sketchy.  This book promises a more real-world take on G.I. Joe and the whole special forces mythos, making for a “Bourne Identity” vibe rather than the more colorful take that G.I. Joe is known for, and I have to say, I am not entirely sold.  A G.I. Joe title, to me, should feel a bit larger than life, and the biggest failing of the big-screen G.I. Joe movies was in the homogenization of the concepts at the heart of G.I. Joe.  While I appreciate the moral ambiguity of a real world tale, and even get behind Cobra posing as a peacekeeping force for evil intent, having G.I. Joe sent in on an assassination mission galls me, and more than half the issue is spent on budget meetings and backroom intrigue.

THE BOTTOM LINE: TOO DARK FOR MY TASTES

There’s a clear vision in this book, and some decent artwork to be had, but I feel like Traviss has stripped out too much of the central conceit for this to be a really successful relaunch of G.I. Joe.  With different characters in play but the same story and art, I might have found it more succcessful, but as it stands, G.I. Joe #1 is a little too grim, a little too real-world and a little too morally gray for me, earning 2 out of 5 stars overall.  It’s not a bad comic, it’s just not a good G.I. Joe comic.

Cobra as a peacekeeping force?  The Joe team disbanded?  Black is white, up is down and short is long, but what are the shattered remains of G.I. Joe gonna do about it?  Your Major Spoilers review of G.I. Joe #1 awaits! G.I. JOE #1 Writer: Karen Traviss Penciler: Steve Kurth Colorist: Kito Young Letterer: Tom B. Long Editor: John Barber Publisher: IDW Publishing Cover Price: $3.99 Previously in G.I. Joe: "G.I. Joe is the code name of an elite special missions force whose mission is to defend the world from Cobra, a ruthless terrorist organization bent on ruling the world." But…
Grim tidings, questionable morality, and too much realpolitik, even as The Baroness impresses.

G.I. JOE #1

Writing
Art
Coloring

Grim tidings, questionable morality, and too much realpolitik, even as The Baroness impresses.

User Rating: 3.45 ( 1 votes)

The Author

Matthew Peterson

Matthew Peterson

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture!

And a nice red uniform.

Previous post

Prop Shop: Building the Destiny hand cannon from foam

Next post

Finally Friday - September 26, 2014

1 Comment

  1. September 26, 2014 at 5:16 pm — Reply

    “I’ve seen a lot of G.I. Joe stories, and the ones that I find the least compelling are the ones that deal with lots of realpolitik and funding issues and the like”

    In concept, I actually think those ideas could work well with the right story and writer. In practice, I haven’t really seen a G.I. Joe story where it has worked for me.

You know you have something to say, say it in the comment section