Like peanut butter and jelly, peanut butter and chocolate or peanut butter and anything, Transformers and G.I. Joe go great together.  IDW is launching a new Transformers vs. G.I. Joe comic and Major Spoilers has your review!

Transformers GI Joe_1_coverTRANSFORMERS VS. G.I. JOE #1
Writer: Tom Scioli, John Barber
Artist: Tom Scioli
Letterer: Tom Scioli
Colorist: Tom Scioli
Editor: Carlos Guzman
Publisher: IDW Publishing
Cover Price: $3.99

Previously in Transformers vs. G.I. Joe: G.I. Joe is America’s special task force responsible for protecting the world from threats such as Cobra.  Transformers are sentient alien robots with the ability to change into vehicles.  This is what happens with the two meet.

I FEEL 5 YEARS OLD AGAIN

The simplest way to describe Transformers vs. G.I. Joe #1 is to imagine what a five year old Transformers and G.I. Joe fan would want in a comic.  Tom Scioli and John Barber have basically written a love letter to the franchises.  It’s a simple start, one that is continuing from the Free Comic Book Day issue, with the Joes meeting Soundwave, his cassettes and Shockwave.  Things don’t go as peacefully as the Joe’s expected, fighting breaks out and by the end Laserbeak and Frenzy meet Cobra.  In a nice twist, the Joes are secretly traveling to Cybertron, which is slowly entering Earth’s orbit.  That ending was something I found unique as we’ve usually seen the two meet on Earth.  This promises some interesting events as the Joes will be the ones on foreign territory for a change.  Hardcore G.I. Joe and Transformers fans will find lots of things to love like the battle in Springfield and Ravage having a voice.  Even the dialogue feels stripped right out of the old Marvel issues.  Five year old Chris loved this issue but the adult still found problems.  While I appreciated the “retro” voice Scioli gives the characters, it often times comes off as silly.  It’s a far cry from the other more serious Transformers and G.I. Joe comics IDW is putting out and those looking for something similar are going to be disappointed.  There is also no recap, so readers who didn’t pick up the FCBD issue will have no idea how or why Snake Eyes lost his face and is living in the woods.  All in all, it ends up being a fun read for fans of Transformers and G.I. Joe, especially those of the early Marvel runs.

THROUGH NOSTALGIA TINTED GLASSES

Reactions I’ve heard to Tom Scioli’s art range from liking it to loathing it, going as far as to call it ugly.  It’s certainly a unique style and one that I haven’t seen in modern comics before.  Like the story, it harkens back to the books from the ’80s and I felt like I was looking at a slightly morphed version.  Each page and panel is packed to the brim with characters and vehicles from the cartoons and toys along with an energy and spirit throughout.  Even so, I can’t honestly say it’s good art and certainly understand people’s complaints.  Scioli is clearly trying to resemble the original comics in his own way and in that respect, succeeds.  His figures and shapes look very, very off and have curvy squiggles all over.  Your feelings on the art will be what makes or breaks the book for you.  There are a couple instances where some better editing and proofing could have occurred.  A word balloon overlaps another in a panel, making the other partly unreadable and the same thing happens with the art.  They’re mistakes that are unforgivable for a mainstream comic such as this and were disappointing to see.  I still give Mr. Scioli credit for taking on so many tasks in one book.  It’s quite impressive.

BOTTOM LINE: GREAT FOR OLD TIMERS, WONKY ART

How much you will like Transformers vs. G.I. Joe #1 depends on two things: your love of the properties and feelings about the art.  There’s enough nostalgia here for old time fans to go nuts over but the art style is a deal breaker for some.  Fans wanting to feel like a kid in 1984 again may want to pick this one up.  I personally had a blast and will now be spending the next hour playing with toys.

 

The Author

Wilson

Wilson

One of the two idiots of Shock 'N Awe Toy Reviews, ever since he was young, Chris has sided with super-villains. At age 8 he became a Decepticon sympathizer. When he turned 18 he left home to become an Agent of A.I.M. He quit at 21 (the costumes were too stupid) and devoted his time to all things geek. His hobbies include making aluminum foil hats, magic, taxidermy and music. Oh, and reading comics. Lots and lots of comics. More nonsense can be followed at @scaabs on Twitter and his YouTube channel, Shock 'n Awe Toy Reviews.

Previous post

Amazing Spider-Man #4 Review

Next post

BCC: Calafiore, Chen, Curtis, Kitchen, and more head to Baltimore

5 Comments

  1. Sean Wade
    July 28, 2014 at 1:32 pm — Reply

    I for one loved it. Everything about this book is intentional. From the lettering, coloring, Steranko layouts, Kirby esc art, etc. All made to look like a TF vs GI JOE comic from the 60’s/80’s, a bit with a modern flair here and there.

    Chris you dislike the bubbles that look like there being blocked. That was intentional too. Now, apparently it didn’t work for everyone, which is why people look at it as an editing mistake. Maybe Scioli was trying to hard. However, as said, it was intentional. The reason Flash bubbles is blocked is because Hawk and Jaye’s firing and talking it BLOCKING IT OUT. Look at the panel, how would you hear what Flash was saying with what both Hawk and Lady J are doing?

    The second one being Shipwreck being talked over by Flagg. Again, apparently not everyone got it, and maybe the reader should have been more informed by the cartoon version of Shipwreck in order to get the Joke of that scene. In any case Flagg is intentionaly talking over Shipwreck. Why? Because nobody cares about what Shipwreck has to say. It’s supposed to be humerous, but again perhaps Scioli was trying to hard.

    Still, there’s is nothing about this comic that is not intentional. I love it.

    • July 28, 2014 at 3:06 pm — Reply

      Thanks for the info. Clearly my somewhat lacking knowledge of G.I Joe led to misunderstanding, which is somewhat a fault of the book though. I still think the gunfire was a mistake but I’ve been wrong before. The fact that this debate is occurring shows that not all the elements worked and the average reader will not get it. Glad you liked the issue, thanks for the review!

  2. Roderick
    July 28, 2014 at 2:32 pm — Reply

    Hey Chris- I feel the panel where the general’s word balloon overlaps Shipwreck’s word balloon was done on purpose – it gave me the feeling that he was speaking over him and gave the panel some verbal energy. I fall into the camp that loves the indie-quirkiness of Scioli art and writing. I appreciate your balanced review and definitely agree about the FCBD issue not being re-capped was a minus.

    • July 28, 2014 at 3:10 pm — Reply

      Thanks for reading. This one was difficult for me to review based on my love of Transformers. I try my best to look at books from the average readers perspective. Luckily, the review system now averages out our ratings for the overall score so it keeps us a little more honest. :)

  3. Sean
    July 28, 2014 at 7:35 pm — Reply

    Hope you review atleast up to issue 3. Interested to see if your views evolve. This issue set up the idea. Next will show us the big idea, Joes vs Transformers on Cybertron. From the art he’s shown expect the next issue to be Transformers Heavy. Scioli got lots of ambitions for this thing. He want this to be his NEW GODS.

You know you have something to say, say it in the comment section