For those of us who lived through the comics boom of the 1990s, it can seem like those years were nothing more than an endless parade of stupid, sexist and ill-advised characters powered by little more than speed lines and avarice.  In truth, there are a great many gems to be had in those years, even in the ranks of the much-maligned ranks of the X-titles.  What manner of tale could break out of the cookie-cutter fighty-fighty and mutant angst?

Your Major Spoilers (retro) review awaits!


In-depth, fascinating character work.
Brilliant dialogue.


Quesada’s art is confusing and does the narrative a disservice.

Overall Rating: ★★★★½



XFactor87CoverX-FACTOR #87
Writer: Peter David/Shana David (assistant)
Penciler: Joe Quesada
Inker: Al Milgrom
Colorist: Marie Javins
Letterer: Steve Dutro/Richard Starkings
Editor: Kelly Corvese
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Cover Price: $1.25
Current Near-Mint Pricing: $2.00

Previously in X-Factor: Originally founded by the core five X-Men, the X-Factor name was co-opted by the United States government for their team of mutants, designed with the hope of fostering better relations between mutants and humans.  The experiment might have been more successful if they hadn’t chosen some of the most volatile and emotionally damaged mutants, the son of Magneto, and the man who will probably forever be known as ‘Cyclops Baby Brother.’  After the massive crossover schmaggegi known as ‘X-Cutioner’s Song’, the members of X-Factor are all emotionally compromised.  Normally, that would mean page after page of repression and snarling, but thankfully the Commission On Superhuman Activities’ insurance covers psychiatric care.  Enter Doc Samson, psychologist to the superhumans.  We begin with Rahne “Wolfsbane” Sinclair, who has been suffering from terrible nightmares…

XFactor871 Thanks to writer Peter David, the dream sequences are full of pop culture references, including a spot on ‘Ren & Stimpy’ parody, cutting edge circa 1993.  When Doc Samson tries to answer her question, he points out her need for acceptance by authority figures, her need to be loved, and the way the two combine into her obvious crush on team leader Havok.  Unfortunately, Samson broaches the topic of Rahne’s adoptive “father”, the late Reverend Craig…


The best part of this sequence comes in the way David takes the established Wolfsbane character, what had then been around for a decade, and pointed out something that might have been obvious from the beginning, if anyone had been really looking for it.  It makes Doc Samson (and, by extension, the writer) look like a genius, and kind of puts Professor Xavier under an unflattering microscope for not having dealt with these issues before.  Speaking of things nobody thought about before, what happens when Samson turns his attention to one of the oldest characters in the entire Marvel Universe?


Petro Maximoff, the son of Magneto had been through three decades of heel/face turns, weird obsessiveness, a failed marriage, ruined relationships and family drama.  What possible explanation could there be for his endless utter douchebaggery?




In two pages, the creative team not only revitalized a character, but explained his inconsistent behavior and seemingly unresolvable character responses, even making me feel bad for the guy.  In short, they proved the old adage that everyone is the hero of their own story, and delivered more characterization than some characters get in ten issues.  Each member of X-Factor gets their moment, from an explanation of Polaris’ ongoing body-image issues…


As an aside, this whole sequence ties into Lorna’s long-term possession by the creature known as Malice (it was the X-Men, just roll with it) and gives a strong emotional back story to Polaris’ adoption of a belt-and-buckles stripperiffic red costume later in this issue, throwing a new light on what would normally have just been Joe Quesada trampin’ up another female superhero, as was the fashion circa 1993.  As for the team strong guy, the man named… uhh…. Strong Guy?  His story is another galvanizing character moment for what was previously only a minor leaguer…


Strong Guy’s transformation from nebbishy nerd child to monstrously mis-proportioned mountain of muscle is tragic, but is also the first attempt to explain how and why a man who is built like Steroid Popeye could have ever existed.  The only real complaint I have is that S.G.’s flashback is the one hurt the most by Joe Quesada’s overly-stylized art, as the schoolchildren shown are nearly as misshapen as Guido himself, in slightly different ways.  The cartoony art pulls me away from the story, something that is even more amplified as we hear the tale of the Multiple Man’s lonely upbringing.


Madrox’s story is another heart-breaker, but the emotional heft is muted by his cartoon floppy hair and vague resemblance to Norville Rogers throughout his two pages.  As for team leader Havok, he relates his inability to relax, his feelings of hyper-awareness to keep his team members safe, always trying to live up to the example of big brother Scott “Cyclops” Summers…


The real kicker to all of this comes as Samson interviews government liaison Valerie Cooper, to get her assessment of the heroes under her care…


…and Valerie getting it all 100% wrong.  20 years ago, I thought this made Val look like a self-serving idiot, but in re-reading the book, I’ve come to the conclusion that Peter was once again giving us a look into a real character, showing that, yes, Val doesn’t really “get” these people, but also that nobody really has an entirely realistic view of what goes on in someone else’s mind.  So often in fiction (especially in comics), the characters soliloquy about every thought and emotion that comes into their head, but X-Factor’s team consists of people with secrets, internal lives and what Neil Gaiman famously called “worlds undreamt of.”  This issue takes six minor league characters, and gives us a peek into their world in ways that most comics can only dream of, to the point where I still feel affection for Quicksilver, Multiple Man and Strong Guy to this day based on this 20-year-old run.  X-Factor #87 has some problematic issues with the art matching the tone of the writing, but given the vintage, it could have been much worse (*coughLiefeldcough*), and delivering characterizing moments that are still being felt today, earning 4.5 out of 5 stars overall.

Rating: ★★★★½


About Author

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture! And a nice red uniform.


  1. SmarkingOut Adam on

    I love when you look back at the 80’s and 90’s X-books. I read these at the time and it is fun to revisit them with you offering your thoughts.

  2. I remember this run of X-Factor being one of my favorite books of all time. I loved the concept of a government “X” team, and the fact that they were all such nearly broken individuals from the start led to some great character moments. Thanks for the reminder Matthew, of course now I have to go digging into my long boxes to find some stuff to re-read.


  3. Didn’t Val get possessed by some random monster(s) at the end of this issue? I think she became evil for a while and tried to sabotage the team or something…it has been a long time since I’ve read this issue but I remember being totally blown away by the simple explanation regarding Pietro’s personality.

    However, I think an Elseworlds DC story touched upon this idea before hand – it was the one where Batman lived in some type of theocracy that had captured the metas before they became heroes; one of them was Barry and the priests in power tried to replicate his powers and one of the people that “received” super-speed could not slow down his “thinking” speed even though his body itself didn’t have super speed, so he was locked in what was essentially a slow motion body for the rest of his life.

  4. Can’t believe it’s been 20 years since this issue came out. I still remember it fairly well, and the Quicksilver stuff especially always really stuck with me.

  5. Even though it’s been 20 years, this was still one of the best stand alone issues that Peter David ever wrote. The explanation of why Quicksilver suffers from Pietro Maximoff Syndrome? Classic.

    I miss writing like this.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.