Here at Major Spoilers there is a lot of love for Gail Simone, but I must admit I have never read anything from her. That changed this week with Batgirl #10…

Batgirl #10
Writer: Gail Simone
Artist: Alitha Martinez
Inker: Vicente Cifuentes
Colors: Ulises Arreola
Letters: Dave Shrape
Editor: Brian Smith

Previously in Batgirl: The Court of Owls had one of their Talon assassins go after Batgirl and her father, Commissioner Gordon. This particular Talon entered the ranks of the Court of Owls after her family has killed by a balloon attack unleashed the Japanese in 1944. After the assassin uses the same method to attack the Gotham P.D. Barbara learns that maybe everyone under a mask is conflicted.


Let me state again that I had no previous experiences with Gail Simone’s writing before this issue of Batgirl. But after reading the first six pages I was in love with her. The opening fight sequence with a running inner-monologue from Barbra was a prime example of why comics are a fantastic medium for story telling. While Barbara is putting a stop to a car jacking she is processing the vigilante role of hospitalizing crooks in the name of protecting the cars of the rich. It is easy to tell that she is conflicted about her slot in the life, even with the past she has faced.

Barbara’s thoughts about her responsibilities to the citizen’s of Gotham are stretched even farther after a conversation with her roommate. Alysia’s words after being thrown in jail for her protesting send Batgirl back to check on the wounded car-jacker she left with building security. Her curiosity leads to some nice punch-punchy times and the revealing of a new threat to Gotham.


With Gail creating waves of emotions and thought through her words, they could have taken it easy in the actual visuals but thankfully Alitha Martinez doesn’t do that here. She expands on the words and gives them a whole new space to grow in. I went through the issue just looking at the characters’ eyes and was blown away by how much emotion poured out of every set. Martinez and the rest of the art team may be the perfect match for Simone’s words.


After finishing my first read through Batgirl #10 I was deeply disappointed in myself for not picking up this title from the beginning. In a single issue she presented a character with Barbara that I felt connected with and cared for just as much as any character that I have read so far. Combine that with the art coming from Alitha Martinez and you have a completely engrossing book. If you couldn’t tell from my gushing already I’m giving this issue 5 out of 5 stars. I will now go “punish” myself for not reading the first nine issues by spending my money to buy every single one.

Rating: ★★★★★


About Author

Zach is a recent college graduate who’s love for consuming media is surpassed only by his love for creating it. He has a firm belief that if we could all just play with LEGOs for 30 minutes a day the world would be a better place. If those two statements don’t tell you everything you need to know about Zach, follow him on Twitter at @zwoolf.


    • ~wyntermute~ on

      ?? Really? There were sentences that I don’t even understand, like: “With Gail creating waves of emotions and thought through her words, they could have taken it easy in the actual visuals but thankfully Alitha Martinez doesn’t do that here. ”

      You call that bit of fluffery “succinct”? I half-expected to see “could of” in a sentence of that quality, instead of the thankfully-proper “could have”. Also, I spotted typos & grammatical violations that an English teacher should’ve corrected in this writer by now. My review of the review? 1.5/5 stars. I really -wasn’t- going to make a fuss about this review, but then I saw you handing out praise that I don’t feel was earned, so… I’m the grumpy Wynter today. ^_^

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.