Or – “People Keep Telling Me This Is Good…”

I’m always fascinated by the weird things that comic fans say.  I was recently told that I HAD to pick up this book because, and I quote, “It’s X-Men and it’s finally good again!”  The thought process seemed to be that if I wasn’t reading X-Men, it was only because I didn’t REALIZE that the titles were in an upswing, and that there was no possible way that I wouldn’t want to jump onboard this title if it was in any way readable.  ReGenesis has seemed to be just another sales gimmick to me, but I figured, at the very least, it was worth giving the new paradigm a look…

WOLVERINE & X-MEN #3
Writer: Jason Aaron
Pencilers: Chris Bachal0/Duncan Rouleau/Matteo Scalera
Inkers: Tim Townsend/Jaime Mendoze/Al Vey/Mark Irwin/Victor Olazaba/Duncan Rouleau/Matteo Scalera
Colorists: Chris Bachalo & Jason Keith
Letterer: Rob Steen
Editor: Nick Lowe
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Cover Price:

Previously, in Wolverine & The X-Men:  A rift in the X-Men has once again led to different teams of mutants with different agendas and different leadership.  This branch of the team has returned to Westchester, the X-Men’s ancestral home, under the leadership of James “Wolverine” Howlett.  With the assistance of some of the most tenured X-Men, Wolverine has chosen to return the concept to that of a school, and has named it for Jean Grey, the X-Men’s ceremonial martyr.  Will the ultimate loner/samurai/ninja/biker hero be able to get it together and play headmaster, or are we just waiting for this new school to blow up like the last?

(Actually, can’t it be both?)
 

AN ART TEAM THAT OUTNUMBERS THE SUPER-TEAM…

The cover art struck me as quite attractive, which is why the sight of the first page, with its not-quite-successful aping of the art of Chris Bachalo, bugged me so much.  Bachalo himself has the ability to make anyone look like a pre-teen with a huge head, and the sight of Captain America and Wolverine in the prologue struck all the wrong notes for me (especially Cap’s bucket helmet and huge chinstrap.)  Still, there’s a ray of hope here, as their discussion lampshades the fact that Quentin Quire is a hugely dangerous sociopath, and even advises that Captain America and the Avengers will be ready to step in should Wolverine’s stewardship of Kid Omega fall apart.  Cut to the present, as the living island Krakoa has attacked the Jean Grey School and made mincemeat of the campus, while another villain has transformed the state inspectors into monsters.  It’s a quick story, with some nice dialogue (Quire’s absolute dismay that his fellow students don’t already know and fear him is priceless) and even the presence of an alien called “Kid Gladiator” can’t kill the infectious fun.

…BUT THEN, THEY SURPRISE ME.

The Beast is here, Wolverine is here, Kitty Pryde is here, and there are myriad references to Claremont-era Shi’ar storylines, but all of this coalesces into something entirely different as the team struggles with their attackers just long enough for Quentin Quire to make his move.  One telepathic conversation later, and Jason Aaron has turned the whole story on it’s head, and impressed the hell out of me.  I’m not gonna ruin the fun for anybody who hasn’t read the issue, but it was a moment that makes perfect sense AND changes the nature of this X-Men team immediately.  The rest of the issue proceeds organically from that moment, and even the inconsistent attempts to ape a single artist can’t torpedo it.  There’s even a nice Maggott reference, which makes me think that this book is aimed at lapsed X-Men fans of Rodrigo’s vintage as much as lapsed fans of my own, and to tell the truth, it might successfully be able to serve both groups.

THE VERDICT AN INTRIGUING START.

I expected that this book would be well-done after all the people I’ve had recommend it to me, but what I didn’t expect was to like Quentin Quire.  Or, for that matter, to like Wolverine shoe-horned into a leadership role…  But both decisions work well here, and Jason Aaron does great work with all the supporting cast, even in the quick-hits that come in and around the big battle.  Had the art been more consistent (or, to be honest, had it been inconsistent in a different style), this one would have been a must-have issue for me.  I’m not a particular fan of Chris Bachalo on superhero titles, though I loved him on Shade, The Changing Man, back in the day, and having half a dozen people ape his style takes a lot away from the storytelling in this issue.  In the final analysis, though, Wolverine & The X-Men #3 does the trick for me, living up to the hype and earning a well-deserved 4 out of 5 stars overall.

Rating: ★★★★☆

Faithful Spoilerite Question Of The Day:  Where is Professor X in all this ReGenesizing?

The Author

Matthew Peterson

Matthew Peterson

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture!

And a nice red uniform.

Previous post

MOVIES: Marvel movies get release updates... AND 3-FREAKIN'-D

Next post

STATUES: Ghostbusters light-up statues in stores now

3 Comments

  1. December 23, 2011 at 12:55 am — Reply

    :( Someone keeps buying the one issue they get in at Hastings so I have to buy it digitally, but for a new reader I’m glad they made a non-DC comic that I can start collecting and not need a graphic novel, or ten, to start.

  2. david_waller@comcast.net
    December 24, 2011 at 6:59 am — Reply

    I really enjoyed Bachalo’s work on the first two issues of this title. I was just settling in for what looked like a decent run of artwork I like and a good/decent story and then I discover there’s a new artist starting with issue 4. I’ll give the new guy a try but I hate when an artist leaves a title after only a couple of issues. Consistency is always appreciated.

  3. December 25, 2011 at 8:45 am — Reply

    it was great book. I know reviewer seem to like bachello on the book but it will be interesting to see what happens next issue when we get the replacement next issue. I’ve seen the new guys work he did the interconnected group shot alternetive covers used to advertiseand revial line ups. it will be interesting to see him draw this. His art reminds me of Art Adams. the epilogue with kade was one the best Xmen seens I have seen in I did not see it coming but it made alot of since and was funny as well as being a great guest shot

You know you have something to say, say it in the comment section