Or – “Eight Bucks?  Does This Book Come With A Gatefold Girlfriend?”

I’ve remarked about the tendency of comic book covers to be nothing but glamour shots of the team, and that tendency doubles when it’s an anniversary or milestone issue.  But I’ll say this for Fantastic Four #600:  They’ve at least given us a CHOICE of which goofy glamour shot we want…

Of course, they’re all REALLY unattractive, but at least one features a pretty nice shot of Susan Richards’ derriere.

Writer: Jonathan Hickman
Penciler(s): Steve Epting/Carmine Di Giandomenico/Ming Doyle/Leinil Francis Yu/Farel Dalrymple
Inker(s): Rick Magyar/Steve Epting/Gerry Alanguilan
Colorist: Paul Mounts/Andy Troy/Jordie Bellaire/Javier Tartaglia/Jose Villarrubia
Letter(s): VC’s Clayton Cowles
Editor(s): Denning, Sankovitch & Brevoort
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Cover Price: $7.99

Previously, in Fantastic Four:

The Thing!  Mister Fantastic!  The Invisible Woman!  The Human Torch!

And about nine other guys at various points in their 50 year history! 

Together, they are the first family of the Marvel Universe, the legendary Fantastic Four!


First of all, I know that it’s rare that Quesada puts pen to paper, what with his new duties, but isn’t a bit arrogant that every big event anniversary issue now comes with a Joe Q. cover?  Especially given that his cover for this issue is one of the ugliest among uglies?  (I did NOT need to see up the Invisible Woman’s nose.)  The actual story portion of the issue ties together a bunch of ongoing plots from the last year of FF, as the Kree Armada invades from space, the hordes of Annihilus attack from the Negative Zone, and the last surviving alternate Reed Richards makes a chessmaster move that worries me A LOT.  Jonathan Hickman has a flair for character in the middle of the kablammicus, and Namor gets a five-panel bit that steals the entire show for me.  The reveal of what the hell has been happening with the Kree and the Inhumans (and Black Bolt’s newfound polyamoury) is a thunderbolt, and each Fantastic Four member gets moments of awesome.  Susan holds off an entire armada (!!) with her force-fields, Bashful Benjy goes toe-to-toe with FOUR Kree Sentries, Reed acts as a human computer, and Spider-Man fights off a horde of Annihilus creatures to defend the portal the the Negative Zone.  And as for the last member of the Fantastic Four…

“But, Matthew,” some of you are saying, “That’s four heroes already!  How can there be another member of the Fantastic Four?”  To which I respond, Welcome to Major Spoilers, because you’re obvious new here…


As the Negative Zone door opens, we see Jonathan Storm, the Human Torch on the other side, with Annihilus himself captured and defeated.  “Pete,” he greets Spider-Man.  “What the heck are you wearing?”  HA!  The main story ends there, but we immediately get a pretty awesome tale that explains what happened to John after the battle with Annihilus lo those many months ago.  For those who no-sold the death sequence and pointed out that we never saw a body, Hickman takes the time to show us in graphic detail the moments after that issue faded to black, as The Human Torch lured the Annihilus Wave into his clutches and released his finishing move ultimate weapon:  The Nova Flame!  We blasts the majority of the army to ash, but is then dismembered by Annihilus himself.  It’s pretty gruesome, and the rather ingenious method used to bring him back is even more so, as we see what Johnny lives through in order to not be dead anymore.  I have to say that the strength of this sequence makes the uncertainty of the original story seem like a feint so that the writer could fake us out thinking it’s just a silly “Is he or isn’t he?” riddle, then punch us in the gut with this a few months later.  Reed’s appearance to claim Johnny’s body is a revelation, a scene that I didn’t even realize that I wanted to see until Hickman delivered it, and overall I’m fairly satisfied with what takes place in the Negative Zone.  Hickman rounds out the issue with a similar behind-the-scenes story that illuminates Black Bolt’s mysterious return and adoption of four new wives, what Galactus is doing about the Galactus Seed on Earth, and the absolutely chilling things that Franklin Richards has been up to while his parents have been distracted…


FF has been a strong title, if a bit inconsistent from issue to issue (probably partly do to the artistic changes), and this story picks up where the last one left off.  The promise of two issues (FF #12 and Fantastic Four #601) in the coming weeks makes me think that we’re going to enter a realm of X-Men style multiple book storylines, which doesn’t actually bother me when Hickman is handling the writing.  The artist changes in this issue actually work to the story’s advantage, with the sole exception of a marked difference in apparent age for the Human Torch between the first & second tales.  All in all, this book is 100 pages of story, five times the normal amount, for a little more than two times the price, which (combined with the quality of what happens inside) helps to offset the much higher price point.  Fantastic Four #600 is a well-done issue, and the FF’s fourth renumbering stunt in the last few years, leading me to honor it by renumbering our star system to give it 13 out of 15 stars overall.  (Of course, I don’t have that kind of room or the ability to reprogram the star generator, so we’ll just call it 4 out of 5.)

Rating: ★★★★☆

Faithful Spoilerite Question Of The Day:  Is a sufficiently cool return from the dead is worth the use of the long-discredited “Someone will DIE!” trope?


The Author

Matthew Peterson

Matthew Peterson

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture!

And a nice red uniform.

Previous post

FRIDAY SING-ALONG: Skyrim Meets Metal

Next post

REVIEW: Invincible #85


  1. November 25, 2011 at 10:30 pm — Reply

    I couldn’t justify picking this up for $8, but I do like Ming Doyle’s art. I met her in person (she’s dating Neil Cicierega, the Lemon Demon / Potter Puppet Pals guy) at a convention. She’s really nice–she’s a big Green Arrow / Black Canary fan, and my wife and I (girlfriend at the time) were dressed up as Ollie and Dinah. Also Neil let me shoot at him with my mini-marshmallow bow.

  2. November 26, 2011 at 2:02 am — Reply

    It is a sad day in the Atomic-cave of Comic Book Wonder, when I need to give such thought on buying one issue of my favorite comic due to cover price. Some of the best stories and series i’ve read have been impulse purchases when I’ve had some change left over. Now I have to balance what I’ll have for dinner, to “is the story worth it and do I take A chance”?

    • Rocket Rooster
      November 26, 2011 at 10:29 am — Reply

      You spoke for me. Times are tough when you can’t just buy a comic. Ah, well. At least we have our health.

  3. Eric (CMonocle)
    November 26, 2011 at 10:55 am — Reply

    It seems like Hickman was toying with the whole death thing, as he has Johnny die countless times only to be reanimated. I also like how he used this as an excuse to upgrade Johnny’s powers.

    I get tired of pointless deaths and resurrections in comics too, but I think this was good for the character. I liked it.

  4. November 27, 2011 at 8:54 am — Reply

    I felt the same way with the high cover price, but as Peterson said, you get 5 times the comic for just a little more than twice the price. It was well worth the price.

    However if Marvel wants me to buy more books, they need to DRAW THE LINE @ $2.99

  5. November 27, 2011 at 3:31 pm — Reply

    For anyone following FF and worried about the price this issue delivers in spades. You get (as mentioned) 5x the pages for 2x the price. You get a VERY solid summary of what’s going on in the Fantastic Four and Future Foundation and everything in between. You get information on all of these that we did not previously have. You get just a good story.

    I was worried about Johnny’s return. With how cheap most of the ‘returns’ have felt recently (I ALMOST liked the return of Steve Rogers but it didn’t jive well compared to this) this was just really well done. The one shot of him coming back and everything else in the scene (Annihilus, Peter, whats being said) it’s just… it felt reinvigorating.


    Offhand does anyone know why the Reed’s from other universe’s had Infinity Gauntlets and weren’t able to use them to fix the problems in their own universes?

  6. November 27, 2011 at 5:44 pm — Reply

    This is a bit of a tough choice for me. On the one hand, it is pointed out that we get more story for the cost, but on the other it’s still a pretty hefty price tag for someone like me that barely gets to justify spending on comics. Do I want to sacrifice variety for more story, or do I want more story bur fewer choices?

    Tough call.

You know you have something to say, say it in the comment section