Or – “For Freakier Imagery, You’d Probably Have To Get Rodrigo Plastered.”

The return of Animal Man to regular monthly storytelling has also led to a return of the 90’s Vertigo sensibilities, as A-Man is stuck in the middle of an invasion by forces of ‘The Rot’, while simultaneously finding his morphogenic powers to be related to another nebulous concept, The Red.  What does The Red do?

Give Matthew nightmares, mostly…

Writer: Jeff Lemire
Artist: Travel Foreman
Colorist: Lovern Kindzierski
Letterer: Jared K. Fletcher
Editor: Joey Cavalieri
Publisher: DC Comics
Cover Price: $2.99

Previously, on Animal Man:  Strange doin’s is afoot at the Baker household…  When his animal-morphogenetic powers started acting up, Buddy “Animal Man” Baker was disturbed, but the real horror began when his daughter Maxine begin exhibiting powers of her own, bringing her beloved dead pets back (albeit in skeletal form.)  Buddy soon found that Maxine’s growing abilities and his own power problems seemed to stem from the same source, and set off with his daughter to explore The Red, a metaphysical realm that seems to be all about the connections between meat beings.  At the same time, a local zoo has become the center of an infestation of something wicked, and evil mutated agents of something called The Rot are loose in Buddy’s home town, with evil intentions…


The first two pages of the issue are a particularly amazing/disturbing convocation of art, as Buddy and Maxine enter The Red together.  She’s smiling and laughing, while her father’s head seemingly melts and reforms in a horrifying mass of flesh.  (If you want to know what I think it looks like, google ‘Teratoma.’  Better yet, don’t, especially if you’re of a sensitive constitution.)  Maxine helps to pull Daddy back together, but things don’t get any less horrifying as we see the rapidly-discorporating forms of The Rot walking the streets…  Although, as Buddy meets the former Animal Men (shades of Swamp Thing’s wonderful ‘Parliament of Trees’ concept), they refer to his powers as an extension of the life web, a connective something-or-other throughout all living things, a thing that they also refer to explicitly in dialogue as The Source.  (I capitalized it because I think the intent is to make us think of Jack Kirby’s Fourth World concept of The Source, especially given the prominence of Darkseid in the relaunched Justice League comic.  It would be pretty awesome if DC is able to tie together all their various concepts by using Kirby’s primal energy field, especially since they’ve been trying to do this for about 15 years anyway.  See also: Genesis ((The 1994 limited series, not the book of the bible (((AHHH!!!  TRIPLE PARENTHESES!  SOMEBODY CALL AN EDITOR!!!!))). )).)


Jeff Lemire cleverly reframes a couple of different Animal Man origins into one, revealing that the aliens who empowered him weren’t truly alien, but avatars of The Red, and that his purpose was NOT to put on a suit and fight crime, but to father their REAL avatar.  Maxine’s destiny?  To spearhead an epic battle, nothing less than the war for life itself.  Battle erupts simultaneously in The Red (Buddy versus monsters) and the real world (Buddy’s wife and son versus OTHER monsters), and I have to say I’m impressed with Lemire’s characterization of Ellen as she is faced with horrible misshapen things.  If I have any complaint about this issue, it’s that the synthesization of Morrison’s A-Man and the later wacky melty Vertigo concepts feels a little too familiar, as though we’re seeing two existing stories melded into one rather than a brand-new one being created, but the issue ends with a strong cliffhanger, and I really do want to see how it all ends….


The visuals this issue are wild, they are imaginative, but most of all, they are creepy as $&@*.  Every page seems to be filled to the gills with the hybrid children of Heironymous Bosch and H.R. Giger, in ways that I haven’t seen since the heydey of Vertigo back in the mid-90’s.  I’ve long maintained that the #3 issues of the New 52 are going to be the ones that are make-or-break for these titles, and Animal Man #3 (for all the vague notions that parts of this are retellings) is up to the challenge, earning 3.5 out of 5 stars overall.  It’s not as strong as the debut issue, but things have to get darker before we get any signs of dawn, and it gets the job done.

Rating: ★★★½☆

Faithful Spoilerite Question Of The Day:  If they do choose to build everything on the spine that is the Fourth World, are they genius or cheese sandwich?



About Author

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture! And a nice red uniform.


  1. Issue one was the only part of (what I read of) the relaunch that made me go “holy expletive”. While both issue two and three haven’t grabbed me as much as the first one even with the ramp up of disturbing art, this is still the title I’m most giddy about each month. Will definately be keeping up with this going forward.

  2. Swamp Thing and Animal Man seem to be having a parallel storyline, of sorts, actually. The Rot is the main bad guy in Swamp Thing, too. The Green and The Red. I like the concept. What I wanna know is where the White Lantern fits into all of this, and if there’s a The Grey, that’s the life that all cities apparently have as shown by that guy who can talk to cities in Stormwatch.

    • I noticed The Rot showing up in both, and the color references (The Red and The Green) as well. I smell a crossover coming…

  3. Antonio Sanciolo on

    ah crud,
    I was holding off buying swamp thing just to be contrary.
    Hoped the mention of “the green” in this issue was just a throwaway!
    Now I’m going to have to buy Swamp Thing and like it even though everyone else does too!

  4. Good call on the familiarity of the story “style.” This felt a lot like Ennis’s run on Hellblazer from the 90’s.

    Still, can’t wait to see what happens next. This issue felt much like a “journey” issue–connecting significant events that happened before and will happen in the future.

  5. Great review, as always.
    I’m a little torn about this issue.
    On one hand, I loved the original Animal Man series and so far this current incarnation is giving me the plotline I wanted to read in the ’90’s.
    On the other hand, I’m not happy that we’re already heading towards a Swamp Thing/Animal Man crossover. I really wanted the New 52 titles to stand on their own for about a year before we started getting bleedover. I chose not to buy Swamp Thing due to budgetary concerns and I don’t want to be peer-pressured into buying extra issues just to understand what’s going to happen in this title.
    I am concerned that this could dilute the quality storytelling in this title and damage its long-term viability.
    I will live in hope.

  6. I have a feeling there might not be crossover as such, but since both take place in the same world, they are facing the same “bad”. More where if you read both you get a special knod, but if you don’t, you’re not really missing the story of that book. This is how crossovers should be in my view. You won’t “have to” read the other books (unlike almost all crossovers lately), but will just see what is going on elsewhere.

    Personally, i’m loving Animal Man, one of the few i’m actually looking forward to each month, and i have no problem with it being like Vertigo. If we have the horrid return of the 90s style anti-heroes in the other books, we should get the good too.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.