Or – “Also Known As Adventure Comics #306 1/2.”

One of the transformative moments in the history of the Legion of Super-Heroes came in the form of their first loss, the death of Lightning Lad at the hands of Zaryan the Conqueror.  Far from destroying the LSH (as it reasonably could have), Garth’s sacrifice instead catalyzed the remaining members to rededicate themselves to taking down pirates and space-whales and such.  Even though he got over it, it was really the moment that turned the Legion from Kal-El’s teenage social club into an honest-to-Klordny army against evil.  It also set the precedent that, unlike MOST superhero stories, there were very real consequences in the Legion’s world… 

Adventure Comics #520
Written by PAUL LEVITZ
Co-feature written by JEFF LEMIRE
Art by KEVIN SHARPE & MARLO ALQUIZA
Co-feature Art by MAHMUD ASRAR & JOHN DELL
Cover by SCOTT CLARK & DAVID BEATY
Published by DC COMICS

Previously, on Adventure Comics:  A trip to the past to recruit the greatest hero of all time actually led to the Legion of Super-Heroes finding a teenaged version of Superman instead.  This young Kal-El joined the LSH on a weekend warrior basis, wearing his costume in their time and fighting alongside the team against their myriad foes.  The question this raises, of course, is whether the costume itself is now a paradox, since the team gave it to him based on the one he wore when he was an adult, a costume that wouldn’t exist until his mom made it in his subjective future.  Did he model his grown-up suit on the one the Legion gave him which was based on his grown-up suit which was based on the one the Legion gave him which was…  Nevermind.

As for the Atom, Ray Palmer has run afoul of a secret organization that has stolen his size-change technology for use in their nefarious activities.  Of course, unlike his suit, their shrinking powers are fatal, causing the ant-sized terrorists to burst like a sausage in the microwave upon use.  More than that, the group has among its members his beloved uncle Dave, the man who treated him like a person when his abusive father wouldn’t.  Now, with The Colony (not THAT The Colony) on his tail, The Atom and Uncle Dave have travelled into a tiny Genesis-world created in case of armageddon, being chased by murderous guys who call themselves ants…

Recent issues of Adventure have dealt with the “in-betweens” of the Legion’s early years, showing us moments like Saturn Girl hooking up with a teammate, Chameleon Boy forming the Espionage Squad and other moments only hinted at in the regular weird-ass broken chronology of the Legion in the Silver Age.  As I began reading this issue, I was filled with trepidation at the thought of pasted-on melodrama on 50 year-old stories.  As tears rolled down Saturn Girl’s face and she wondered how many more heroes she killed, I started to worry more.  Then, something weird happened:  Supergirl appeared.  Not just Supergirl, but the current mini-skirt and half-shirt version of Kara Zor-El from Superman/Batman circa 2008.  I don’t know why this struck me as so odd, other than the fact that it reinserts Supergirl officially in LSH history, restoring another piece of pre-Crisis continuity.  Except that it doesn’t.  Bygones…  The team sets up the weird little lightning crypt for their lost member, then takes off to give Zaryan a piece of their collective mind.  And fists.  Mostly fists…  Supergirl, Ultra Boy and Kal-El rock the house, while Mon-El puts in a quick cameo appearance, and Brainiac wonders how much stupider his team can possibly get.  We get a pretty detailed retelling of Adventure #306, leading into a bad-ass power walk for Saturn Girl as she decides to be the best leader her team has ever seen, and not coincidentally to find a cure for her mostly-dead boyfriend.  It’s not as bad as I thought it could have been, and the art is pretty delightful.  Still can’t get past that Supergirl thing, though.

Oh, Atom, Atom, Atom.  What in the world are you doing in this book, anyway?  Returning to his old sword-and-sorcery ways, he takes on the members of the Colony hand-to-hand, until they start blowing to pieces again.  Ray manages to save one, and pumps him for information, revealing that the ultimate aim of the project is to get Ray’s stash of white-dwarf star matter so that they can start shrinking without, y’know, dying.  Atom watches in horror as the last guy dies, but not before destroying his size-belt with a stab from a sai.  Of course, the angle of the shot seems like it would also disembowel Ray, but nevermind.  Uncle Dave acts weird, says his belt was mysteriously destroyed as well, and suddenly disappears as The Atom is attacked by giant robotic insects.  Yeah, there’s NO way that Uncle Dave is involved in anything untoward or inappropriate at all, is there?  Gyaah.  Still, it’s well-drawn, so we got that going for us…

When DC announced that Adventure Comics would be losing it’s Co-Feature, I wasn’t terribly upset, as aside from Mahmud Asrar’s art, there’s not much going on in the Atom story.  I’m just not feeling the whole “lost family member” vibe, and the Colony’s motives have been inscrutable from the beginning, making it all very obscure.  Add to that the fact that I really want to know how Ray would respond to the brutal murder of his protege, and this whole arc is kind of a bust.  As for the Legion story, it’s one of the strongest (if not THE strongest) of this arc, with realistic emotion from teenagers who lost one of their own, that never quite makes it into the realm of melodrama.  My minor complaints are the high-profile of the team’s super-strong & invulnerable members in the team sequences (there are a lot of players in the LSH, and it always suffers when we focus only on the powerhouses) and one minor captioning problem.  I’m sure that some readers didn’t even notice, but Invisible Kid I, Lyle Norg, is identified as Invisible Kid II, Jacques Foccart, which bugs the crap out of me, but isn’t a fatal flaw.  All in all, it’s an imbalanced but not terrible issue overall, with excellent art throughout the book.  Adventure Comics #520 is slightly better than okay, but better than it might have been, earning a composite score of 3 out of 5 stars overall.  If we get Mon-El out of the zone, this is potentially really good stuff…

Rating: ★★★☆☆

Faithful Spoilerite Question Of The Day:  If I know that the reveal will be anti-climactic and probably a bad idea, why do I want to see the re-telling of Supergirl’s joining?  Am I just a glutton for punishment?

The Author

Matthew Peterson

Matthew Peterson

Once upon a time, there was a young nerd from the Midwest, who loved Matter-Eater Lad and the McKenzie Brothers... If pop culture were a maze, Matthew would be the Minotaur at its center. Were it a mall, he'd be the Food Court. Were it a parking lot, he’d be the distant Cart Corral where the weird kids gather to smoke, but that’s not important right now... Matthew enjoys body surfing (so long as the bodies are fresh), writing in the third person, and dark-eyed women. Amongst his weaponry are such diverse elements as: Fear! Surprise! Ruthless efficiency! An almost fanatical devotion to pop culture!

And a nice red uniform.

Previous post

Art Appreciation Moment of the Day: Stanley Lau

Next post

Archie Comics Sneak Peek of the Week

8 Comments

  1. averijjoe
    November 4, 2010 at 4:25 pm — Reply

    It might be. Though, sometimes it’s nice to see a different take on an older story, despite the pains it takes to keep all your continuity straight. I’ve spent long conversations explaining to friends that points in comic book movies are different, and why the do or don’t make sense. Still, it rarely lessens my enjoyment of the retelling or the original.

  2. adriana
    November 4, 2010 at 4:35 pm — Reply

    Great review, Matthew! I wanted to know: Would you still be with the series if you weren’t reviewing it?

    On Supergirl+LOSH: they covered this in the recent Supergirl Annual. It’s okay (mostlybecauseBrainiac5isinit).It’s a really long issue devoted mostly to making references to the old comics on every page rather than character building. Supergirl is on her way back from something or another and her ship gets time wiggled into the past and she hangs out there, becomes a member, etc.

    • November 5, 2010 at 8:17 pm — Reply

      On Supergirl+LOSH: they covered this in the recent Supergirl Annual. It’s okay (mostlybecauseBrainiac5isinit).It’s a really long issue devoted mostly to making references to the old comics on every page rather than character building. Supergirl is on her way back from something or another and her ship gets time wiggled into the past and she hangs out there, becomes a member, etc.

      So, I was right, it is completely disappointing…

  3. November 6, 2010 at 9:18 pm — Reply

    Great review, Matthew! I wanted to know: Would you still be with the series if you weren’t reviewing it?

    Probably, yes. I’m a glutton for punishment when it comes to the Legion.

  4. Darrell Lawrence
    November 12, 2010 at 1:54 pm — Reply

    The Legion didn’t give Superboy his costume. Ma Kent did in the Superman Secret Origins issues.

    Also, Supergirl appeared at the original Lightning Lad funeral, so her appearing here is not a big thing. Especially since the very enjoyable Supergirl Annual re-established her membership in the Legion, making the old Supergirl-Legion stories pretty much intact. Similar to what happened with Superboy and his old stories, in fact.

    There is page/panel that I have never seen drawn though, and it just amazed me that I had never seen it before- Mon-El, Kal-El ad Kara Zor-El standing next to each other. Sure, there have been big lay-out team shots of the entire LoSH, but even they never had the three of the most powerful Legionnaires standing side by side. This was the first time I’d ever seen that, and I am talking about Superboy, not Superman, in this case.

    • November 12, 2010 at 6:42 pm — Reply

      Also, Supergirl appeared at the original Lightning Lad funeral, so her appearing here is not a big thing. Especially since the very enjoyable Supergirl Annual re-established her membership in the Legion, making the old Supergirl-Legion stories pretty much intact. Similar to what happened with Superboy and his old stories, in fact.

      I missed that story, and so was unaware that Kara was part of this Legion continuity again.

      • Darrell Lawrence
        November 12, 2010 at 6:58 pm — Reply

        I personally recommend the Annual. And since this is Major Spoilers… prepare to be spoiled LOL

        In current continuity, it’s Supergirl that “encourages” Saturn Girl to go with that pink bikini costume from the 79’s.

        • Darrell Lawrence
          November 12, 2010 at 6:59 pm — Reply

          70’s, not 79’s LOL

          Damn Ferengi keyboard.

You know you have something to say, say it in the comment section